Nestled in the heart of New Holland, Pennsylvania, Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant stands as a cherished local establishment dedicated to bringing the authentic tastes of Italy to our community. Located conveniently at 351 W Main St, our restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it is a warm, inviting space where friends and family gather over exceptional food crafted with passion and tradition. For years, we have committed ourselves to the art of Italian cooking, focusing on fresh ingredients, time-honored recipes, and a dedication to genuine hospitality that makes every guest feel like part of the Palermo family.
Our culinary philosophy centers on simplicity and quality. We believe that the best Italian food relies on the inherent flavor of high-quality components, prepared with care. Whether you are craving a classic, perfectly blistered pizza straight from our oven, a hearty pasta dish simmering in rich sauce, or one of our many other traditional Italian specialties, Palermo Pizza offers an experience that transports you straight to the sun-drenched streets of Italy. We understand that dining out is about more than just sustenance; it’s about creating memories, celebrating milestones, and enjoying a moment of true culinary pleasure. This dedication to both flavor and atmosphere is what sets Palermo Pizza apart in the New Holland dining scene.
We take immense pride in our heritage and strive to honor the culinary traditions passed down through generations. Every dish leaving our kitchen reflects this deep respect for authentic Italian preparation methods. From the slow fermentation of our pizza dough to the careful layering of fresh herbs and spices in our sauces, attention to detail is paramount. Our goal is simple: to provide consistently delicious, satisfying meals in an environment that is both comfortable and vibrant. When you choose Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant, you are choosing quality, tradition, and a commitment to making your dining experience memorable.
Key Highlights of the Palermo Experience
Discover what makes Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant a local favorite:
Authentic Italian Craftsmanship: We adhere strictly to traditional Italian cooking techniques, ensuring that every bite delivers genuine, time-tested flavor. Our commitment to authenticity is evident in everything from our hand-tossed pizzas to our slow-simmered sauces, providing a true taste of Italy right here in New Holland.
Commitment to Freshness: Quality ingredients are the foundation of great Italian food. We prioritize sourcing the freshest produce and premium components available, ensuring that the vibrant, natural flavors shine through in every meal we prepare for our valued patrons.
A Welcoming Community Hub: More than just a restaurant, Palermo Pizza aims to be a cornerstone of the local community. We foster an atmosphere that is friendly, relaxed, and perfect for any occasion, whether it’s a quick weeknight dinner or a special family celebration.
Diverse Menu Offerings: While our name suggests pizza mastery, our menu extends far beyond. We offer a comprehensive selection of classic Italian entrees, appetizers, and desserts, ensuring there is something delightful for every palate and craving.
Your Table Awaits at 351 W Main St
Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant invites you to stop by our location at 351 W Main St, New Holland, PA 17557, United States. We are eager to share our passion for Italian cuisine with you. Whether you are a long-time resident or just passing through Lancaster County, we promise a dining experience characterized by exceptional food and heartfelt service. Our team is dedicated to ensuring your visit is nothing short of perfect, offering the finest in traditional Italian flavors prepared with modern care. Come taste the tradition; come experience the warmth of Palermo Pizza.
We look forward to welcoming you soon to enjoy a truly satisfying Italian meal that honors the rich culinary history of Italy while serving the needs of our wonderful New Holland community.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Groups
Locals
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Menus
Photos
Reviews Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant
Jacqueline Leming
17-12-2025
A traditional awesome pizza parlor with fantastic pizza that oozes cheese in every bite. A staff that is friendly and knows their patrons by name. Prices are very reasonable and the menu is big. Go visit them and definitely try the anchovies - LOL
Service
Dine in
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reservation
Reservations not required
Group size
3-4 people
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Parking
You can dine in or take out. Cards and cash taken. Right near shopping areas.
RICHARD LAROCCO
27-11-2025
Great food and service with and amazing value!!!! The Sicilian pizza is light and Fluffy with a crisp bottom. A real hidden gem!!
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pizza, Salad, Sub, Cheesesteak, Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Sticks, Steak Calzone, Pepperoni Pizza
Mark Rhoderick
11-11-2025
We ordered a cheese pizza and the chicken parmagiana dinner - that came with a salad and garlic bread. The garlic bread had sauce on it, which I thought was a little odd, but it was ok. The same sauce (I think) was on the spaghetti that came with the chicken parm, the pizza and the garlic bread. It was too sweet - honestly the spaghetti tasted like chef-boy-ardee (?) canned sauce. We couldn't really eat it. The pizza was better, the cheese and crust were good, but again I wasn't crazy about the sauce.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 3
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 3
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free of charge parking lot
Esther Stoltzfus
09-10-2025
We were here on a Monday night, it wasn’t full at all, and the place was pretty quiet. The food was delicious! We had a 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 Supreme pizza and the Supreme is “loaded” and they have great hot wings too.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Gary
23-07-2025
No wait to seat. Food was plentiful & good. Becky was our waitress & she was very friendly & on top of things. You will take leftovers home unless you're really hungry 😋. The fettuccine alfredo with chicken was excellent. Nice salad & like a loaf of homemade warm bread came with the meal. Everyone there was very friendly like you're there everyday. Great place.
Service
Dine in
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Group size
2 people
Seating type
Indoor dining area
K L
15-06-2025
It is a casual restaurant. Our waitress, Becky, is one of the best waitresses that have served us for a while. Becky paid attention to our needs, suggested options, smiled a lot, seemed like was having fun, constantly was cleaning the table and made our night special.
The taste of all the food was good. It does not have the same Italian taste as genuine pizza or pasta but to be an American Italian restaurant, it was good.
The portions of the food was super decent, one plate can serve two people.
I would definitely come back again.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pizza
Wheelchair accessibility
I visited the restaurant with someone in a wheelchair, tables and restrooms are accesible.
Heisenberg
12-04-2025
The pizza here is good and cheap. Also large servings for food. The waitress is fast and courteous, food always comes out hot.
They have the best bread for their subs that I've found in the New Holland/Leola/Brownstown area. $10.06 for a Large Italian ain't bad either. It's enough to split between two people.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Stuffed Pizza, Pizza, Fries, Sub, Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Sticks, Pepperoni Pizza
Parking space
Somewhat difficult to find parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Eliza Taylor
20-03-2025
Most ridiculous experience I have ever had ordering from a restaurant. My husband ordered a basic pizza with extra cheese, bacon and garlic. We added a side of fries and mozzarella sticks. Not only were they 20 minutes late With the pizza, upon arriving home, we noticed that someone had put literal tablespoons of garlic all over our pizza. When someone orders the garlic, I don’t believe that they are hoping to get tablespoons of garlic in their mouth every time they take a bite of pizza. It was gross… not even edible…. In addition, our mozzarella sticks were not cooked and the french fries were cold the most basic things that a pizza shop should be able to make. because we had four children and didn’t have time to deal with it, my husband decided to start making macaroni and cheese. We called the pizza shop and told them what had happened instead of them apologizing and offering a refund, They begin arguing and insinuating that we were trying to rip them off and that we must return the unused food in order to get a refund. I told them that I had children and that it was ridiculous for them to expect me to drive all the way back when I’m trying to take care of kids and they already inconvenienced us by making horrible food , needless to say I actually did put two children and one of them a baby and drove to the pizza place which was 10 minutes away. I asked them upon arrival to please come out and get the pizza because I had a baby in the car and I couldn’t come inside. Even though they told me to bring the pizza back, they refuse to come out and get the pizza so I had to quickly exit the car and left the pizza inside with one of the waitresses And ran back out so I could be with my baby who didn’t want in the car. I called back and asked for them to refund our card now that they had the unused food. they refused to refund and the owner got on the phone and started screaming at me And told me he was gonna call the police on me. He also accused me of being somebody who causes problems in his shop all the time except we never order food from there so he must be confusing me with somebody else. It’s very obvious that they have problems with numerous customers , we live over in East Earl and normally go elsewhere but because they were closed on Monday we decided to try this place . My family and friends order from Palermo but I’m sure after the story gets out people will think twice. No one wants to have the police called on them for someone messing up their order or a restaurant owner not taking responsibility for their mistakes. We can easily dispute this on the credit card, which will be happening. I was just trying to show them and honor their request to return the pizza which I didn’t need to do. Literal mouthfuls of garlic all over our pizza. Disgusting gross food. Never again.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1
Brian Ducharme
19-01-2025
Great spot for lunch. They have a good variety of pizza on display to choose from.
They were very friendly and hard working. Very busy at lunch but people were served quickly. I had a slice of the Sicilian pizza and a meat roll. Both were excellent and very reasonably priced. Definitely will go back
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Melody Bauer
02-01-2025
This place does Italian right. Everything we ordered was quite delicious and the portions are large enough to share. We actually went there twice while we were in town. The second time we had a bit more of a wait for one in our party to get their food due to a server error. She was quite apologetic and the food was prepared and brought out quickly. This place will be our go to when we are in the New Holland area again.
Service
Dine in
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reservation
Reservations not required
Special events
No special event
Recommendation for vegetarians
Somewhat recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Vegetarian options
While there wasn't a specific vegetarian section to the menu,it was easy enough to figure out vegetarian options as the description of each dish was easy to understand.
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Kid-friendliness
There is a kids menu
Wheelchair accessibility
It is a no stairs restaurant as far as I could tell.
Reviews Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant